Skip to main content

My Fantasy Self and the Crochet Lies I've Told Myself

 

You know who has lied to me more than anyone else? Me. Specifically, my fantasy self—that idealized version of me who’s effortlessly stylish, endlessly organized, and crochets elaborate heirlooms with perfect tension and zero frogging.


Turns out… she’s full of it.


If you’re not familiar with the idea of a “fantasy self,” it’s the version of you that you imagine you could be, or wish you were. Often inspired by social media, childhood influences, or those magical makers we follow online, this fantasy self can lead us into some truly questionable crochet decisions. And oh boy, do I have some stories.


The Fantasy Purchases

Let’s talk yarn first. My fantasy self loves blanket yarn. She’s seen the hoodies, the plushies, the amigurumi animals. She told me I’d love working with it.


I don’t. It’s bulky, it’s tough on my hands, and it’s just not fun for me to use. Has it sat in my stash forever? Yep. Could I maybe still make a baby blanket with it someday? Probably. But the truth is—I bought it for a version of me that doesn’t really exist. Watch my finger knitting VIDEO HERE.


Then there’s the Pumpkin Bobble Blanket of Doom. Three pounds of burnt orange Pound of Love, bought on sale with the intention of making a bobble-stitch lapghan that would look like tiny pumpkins. Sounds adorable, right? 


Except... have you ever crocheted an entire bobble-stitch blanket? That’s a full-time job. Fantasy Shannon was up for it. Real Shannon is not. For my Fall Project Playlist CLICK HERE.


I've totally changed my mind on several yarns along my crochet journey, read about IT HERE.

Hooks, Tools, and Instagram Aesthetics

Crocheters don’t have a ton of tools, but that doesn’t mean we’re immune to fantasy-self shopping sprees. I’ve seen the handcrafted hooks. The swoon-worthy wood grains. The perfect product photos with the cozy vibes.


And I’ve definitely convinced myself that I needed them—to complete the aesthetic, to match the yarn, to be that person.


Meanwhile, my 20-year-old basic hook still works like a charm. But fantasy me loves a vibe, and she’s very persuasive.


Projects That Don’t Spark Joy

Sometimes, it’s not just about what we buy. It’s about what we don’t make—because our fantasy self tells us it’s not trendy, not exciting, not cool enough. Watch THIS VIDEO to see several projects I just can't seem to finish! Here's the BLOG POST with more info.


Or READ THIS BLOG POST about my experience with crocheting a temperature blanket.


My friend and crochet tutor loves to crochet baby clothes. She sticks to what brings her joy and doesn’t worry about what's trending on TikTok. I admire that. But me? I’ve tried to follow trends and joined CALs that were way above my skill level. Spoiler: I ended up frustrated and burnt out.


My fantasy self loves amigurumi. Real me does not.


The Worst Lie of All

But you know what the worst lie is? “You’ll remember that.”


No, Shannon. You won’t.


I’ve forgotten hooks, rows, pattern ideas, yarn names, colorways, and entire plans because I didn’t write them down. My fantasy self thinks she has a flawless memory and excellent organization skills. Real me is over here trying to decipher what “WIP BOBBLE THNG??” written on a sticky note means.


Learning to Love the Real Me

It’s okay to dream, to plan, to aspire. It’s great to try new stitches and work with new fibers. But if we get too caught up in the fantasy, we stop enjoying the reality of where we are—what we actually like, what brings us joy, and what fits our life right now.


Being honest about that has helped me rehome yarn I’ll never use, stop impulse buying for imaginary gift projects, and appreciate the maker I really am. (And yes, I’m writing things down now.) THIS VIDEO shows how I decided what yarns needed to go.


So if your fantasy self is whispering in your ear at the yarn store, maybe pause. Take a breath. Ask if it’s you who wants that mohair, or the version of you who never has to frog it.


Spoiler: frogging mohair is never fun.

Watch the YouTube video here!




Awhile back, I did a silly collab with some of my YouTube friends called 2 Yarny Truths and 1 Lie, for a few laughs, watch that VIDEO HERE!


Popular posts from this blog

My Top 5 Favorite Places to Buy Yarn Online (Updated for 2026!)

  Over the past year, I’ve noticed a huge spike in views on my older blog post about my favorite online yarn shops. And while I’m flattered that so many people still find it helpful, it was definitely time for an update! A lot has changed since I first made that list: I’ve explored new shops ( Huge inspo HERE ) My yarn taste has changed ( Read more HERE ) And… Joann officially closed it's doors for good ( Shop HERE instead ) So today, I’m sharing my current top five favorite places to buy yarn online as of December 2025 going into 2026. If you love yarn variety, great prices, rich color palettes, and discovering new fibers, this list is for you. 1. Wool Warehouse: (UK) My #1 Forever Favorite If you’ve been around my channel for a while, this one won’t surprise you! Wool Warehouse is hands-down my favorite place to buy yarn online for several reasons: Their house brand Yarnsmiths is fantastic Affordable, soft, and available in so many colors - especially the wa...

New to Hobby Lobby? Here’s What You Need to Know About Shopping for Yarn

  If you're new to shopping for yarn at Hobby Lobby, let me help you avoid some rookie mistakes. I’ve learned a lot over the years, and today I’m breaking it all down so you can shop like a seasoned pro, especially when those big clearance sales roll around! Start with the Weekly Sale Schedule First things first: Hobby Lobby runs on a weekly rotating sale schedule . That means every week, different departments go on sale. The yarn section, is it's own department. When it’s that department’s turn, all the yarn will be 30% off. Here’s the catch: that sale only lasts a week, and the schedule rotates every other week. So if you’re walking into the store when yarn isn’t on sale, it has switched to a fabric sale week. I advise checking online before shopping and planning accordingly.  Hobby Lobby’s Yarn Brands Hobby Lobby carries a few big-name brands, like Lion Brand, but the real stars of the show are their private label yarns. These are exclusive to Hobby Lobby and in...

Don't Panic! Here's An Alternative Yarn

Perfect Replacement for Big Twist If you’ve been a fan of yarn brands like Big Twist and K&C but are now worried about finding suitable replacements, I have great news for you! While these brands may not be as easily accessible as before, there’s a fantastic alternative that offers an incredible variety of yarns at competitive prices— Herrschners . Why Herrschners? Herrschners is a well-known name in the crafting world, and while they have only one physical location in Stevens Point, Wisconsin, they ship nationwide and even internationally! Whether you’ve shopped from them before or are completely new to their selection, you’ll be pleased to know that many of the yarns you love from Joann’s can be found through Herrschners, often at similar or even better prices. Exploring Herrschners Yarn Selection Herrschners offers an extensive range of yarns, including well-known brands like Premier, Lion Brand, Yarnspirations, and Red Heart. They also carry their own house brands, which can ...